Who invented Ctrl+C and Ctrl+V? The story of copy and paste

Before computers, cutting and pasting meant scissors and glue. Meet Larry Tesler, the editor built for a publisher and the reason behind the letters X, C and V.

You copy a payment key someone sent you on WhatsApp, open your banking app and paste it. You copy a website address and paste it into the browser. You select a paragraph, press Ctrl+C and Ctrl+V. It’s so automatic it feels like it has always existed.

It hasn’t. Copy and paste was invented, it has a first and last name, and it started in an unexpected place: a publisher of school textbooks. And there’s more: today, October 28, marks exactly 29 years since one of its inventors took the stage and explained why the shortcuts are these letters and not others.

Before computers, it was scissors and glue

Long before there was a “Paste” button, book and magazine editors were already cutting and pasting. Literally: they took the printed text, cut the paragraphs apart with scissors and glued them onto a new sheet in the right order. That practice was common at publishers for decades, according to the English Wikipedia entry on cut, copy, and paste.

The problem with “modes”

In the early 1970s, editing text on a computer was a job for specialists. Editing programs worked in “modes”: you entered command mode to give orders and edit mode to write. If you forgot which mode you were in, disaster was guaranteed.

Hansen Hsu, a curator at the Computer History Museum in California, gave an example to American radio network NPR: in one of those editors, typing the word “EDIT” in the wrong mode selected the entire text, deleted everything and left just a “T” behind.

One person who was very bothered by this was Larry Tesler, a programmer born in New York in 1945, with a math degree from Stanford. In early 1973 he joined Xerox PARC, Xerox’s research center in Palo Alto, California, IEEE Spectrum magazine recounts. And he arrived with a fixed idea: get rid of modes.

The magazine describes a test Tesler ran with Sylvia Adams, a newly hired secretary at the lab, before she got used to the text editors there. He asked how she would make revision marks on a text directly on the screen. The way she described it had no modes at all. But when she tried the mode-heavy editor the lab used, she struggled even to get out of it.

Gypsy, an editor built for a publisher

Xerox owned a school textbook publisher, Ginn and Company, and wanted to bring computers into the work of the people who prepared books. Tesler teamed up with Tim Mott, who worked at Ginn, to create a text editor for those non-tech people. Mott told NPR that the user they had in mind was a woman in her early sixties who had spent her whole life working in publishing.

The result was called Gypsy. A memo by the two, from April 1975, records that the system was delivered to Ginn in March of that year. It ran on the Alto, an experimental Xerox computer that already used a mouse.

In Gypsy, you selected the text with the mouse and chose CUT or PASTE. The cut text went into a temporary “wastebasket”, from which it could be pasted somewhere else. It was the grandfather of the clipboard, that invisible place where whatever you copied lives. The names of the actions came straight from publishing: according to Mott, Tesler borrowed the term from the old scissors-and-glue practice, NPR reports.

The Computer History Museum holds a video of Tesler demonstrating Gypsy on a restored Alto, cutting and pasting as if it were the most normal thing in the world.

From Xerox to Apple

The idea spread through the lab and reached Smalltalk, a programming language created at PARC itself, according to the entry on Gypsy. In 1980, Tesler left Xerox for Apple, where he went to work on the Lisa, IEEE Spectrum recounts. According to Tesler himself, the Lisa was meant to be a very easy computer to use, for office workers who had never touched such a machine.

On October 28, 1997, Tesler and Chris Espinosa, another Apple veteran, told this story at a talk at the Computer History Museum. The transcript of the conversation has some delicious details. In August 1980, the Lisa’s edit menu had “Cut”, “Paste” and something called “Dupe”, for duplicate, instead of copy. One reviewer on the project preferred commands like “Move”, “Copy” and “Delete”, but in user tests, people preferred cut and paste, by a small margin.

The Lisa hit stores in 1983 and the Macintosh in 1984. Those were the machines that popularized cut, copy and paste, according to Wikipedia.

Why X, C, V and Z?

Now for the part you came to read. In that same 1997 talk, Tesler explained that Apple reserved these shortcuts so they would be the same in every program. And each letter has a reason, according to the transcript:

  • X to cut, because it looks like a cross-out, that “X” we draw to strike something.
  • V to paste, because it resembles a little arrow pointing down, as if saying “this is where it goes”.
  • C to copy, for “copy”, and conveniently next to the other two.
  • Z to undo, because it was the closest key. According to Tesler, the team figured people would be undoing a lot.

Look at your keyboard: Z, X, C and V sit side by side, in the left corner of the bottom row.

On the Mac, the shortcuts use the Command key, the one with the cloverleaf symbol. Since the PC keyboard didn’t have that key, the Windows world used Ctrl. And it didn’t happen right away: a Microsoft support article recalls that Windows 3.0 cut with Shift+Delete, copied with Ctrl+Insert and pasted with Shift+Insert. The Ctrl+X, Ctrl+C and Ctrl+V combinations only arrived with Windows 3.1.

“Don’t Mode Me In”

Tesler took the fight against modes seriously for the rest of his life. He had a personalized license plate reading “NOMODES” and liked to repeat the motto “Don’t Mode Me In”, according to Wikipedia. After Apple, he worked at Amazon and Yahoo, and he died in February 2020, at 74, as Computerworld reported.

I’ve been programming since I was 11 and I’ve lost count of how many times I press Ctrl+C and Ctrl+V in a single day. On your phone, it’s the same idea in different clothes: hold your finger down, “Copy” appears, hold it again, “Paste” appears. No scissors, no modes.

And that’s what’s worth keeping from this story. Copy and paste wasn’t born from a genius trying to impress other programmers. It was born from someone looking at a newly hired secretary and at a publisher that worked with scissors and glue, and asking: how do we make this simple for that person? Fifty years later, that question still applies to every new technology that lands in your hands.

Keep readingSee all →